Four hours

It took me four hours today to write and polish a disposition e-mail to the author(s) of a submission. This was a manuscript that I enjoyed very much but for a variety of reasons could not publish, and I owed the author(s) some good advice, or at least the best advice I could give. When I began this editing gig, I’d frequently spend that much time on a disposition e-mail for almost any manuscript, and I’m still spending lots of time on R&R (revise-and-resubmit) e-mails.

And while I spend some time on rejection letters, they usually don’t require as much time as an R&R request (would that be an R&R R?), because the key thing about R&R is to provide as focused feedback as I can — that’s both fair to authors and sanity-saving for me. Rejections require an explanation of why a work is either not appropriate for the journal or technically weak, but there is less of the social-contract obligation of an R&R. After all, if the author(s) revise and submit to another journal, they will (quite properly) have an entirely different set of eyes looking at the material.

The next few e-mails are for R&Rs, and I think they’ll be shoved back to sometime in the weekend, because they may take some time, too!

If you enjoyed this post, please consider subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader, and sign up for my irregular newsletter below!