Sorry, those of you told you were talented: Effort still matters much more

David Hambrick and Elizabeth J. Meinz, arguing that Talent Matters in today’s New York Times Sunday review section:

But working memory capacity made a statistically significant contribution as well about 7 percent, a medium-size effect

This was in comparison to total practice time, which contributed “nearly half of the performance differences.” This is from a Meinz and Hambrick 2010 article in Psychological Science about piano performance,1 with the 7% reference to the increased variance in performance ratings explained when you add the working-memory measure to the practice-time measure.

I would not call it a “medium-size effect” given the dominance of practice time over the working-memory measure. It’s much smaller than the effect of practice (which accounts for 45% of the variance). My quick reading as an outsider to the field: Meinz and Hambrick look like they’ve set up a straw-man argument. Does anyone really think effort is all that matters, or just that it matters much more than anything you could call native talent?

If you enjoyed this post, please consider subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Notes

  1. Added 11/26/11: I forgot to note in writing this to indicate that the study was about rated piano performances. []

2 responses to “Sorry, those of you told you were talented: Effort still matters much more”

  1. Glen S. McGhee

    Sadly, I am now of the opinion that MOST talent is wasted.

  2. CCPhysicist

    The abstract indicates that they attacked a straw man. Who could possibly claim that “expert performance is solely a reflection of deliberate practice”. Gladwell didn’t, since he singled out a 120 IQ as another element.

    It looks to me like this article was marketed to get their names and their university’s names into the Times.

    I’m with Glen. I see this all of the time. People who got by on “talent” but never learned to work hard hit a wall when practice starts to matter. Often that is when they get to college.