Why I recommended Canvas as an LMS

My role in the group evaluating LMS options ended yesterday, and I don’t know the recommendations of other individuals in the group, though I get sense of where we’re headed as an institution. For my part, after looking at Blackboard 9.1, Moodlerooms/joule, and Canvas, I recommended Canvas. We have a lot of transitions to plan at this point no matter what the institution’s choice is, and Canvas is relatively new, but I am confident I made the right recommendation. Some thoughts I’ve had in the last week, as I’ve built the summer course structure into Canvas (this is a face-to-face offering of an upper-division course in Schools and Society, what’s also sometimes called Social Foundations–I’m using the “free to teachers” version of Canvas, unless/until there’s a contract between USF and Canvas this summer):

  • That took about a quarter of the time it would have taken in Blackboard.
  • That took about a quarter of the time it would have taken to build in Respondus and upload to Blackboard.
  • I look like I’m in some 1960s movie, but it took about three minutes to record a short video greeting for the whole class that’s the first thing they see.
  • Oh, I can spend half a minute to leave a ten-second video greeting for each student after they accept the email invitation into the course.
  • Hmmn… okay, I can see a workaround to get what I want to happen (a sequence of assignments, so students have to complete a quiz on plagiarism before they can upload papers, but without having unnecessary girders/infrastructure showing).
  • I think I’ll give them hints about Canvas and let the interested students show the others what they can do.
  • On second thought, I may definitely want to show the “What if?” feature in Grades and talk about it explicitly.
  • Anticipated grading workflow: paper copy of rubric, scribble notes and a two- or three-sentence script for each, then use Speedgrader on “mute assignment” to score papers and use script from paper rubric to record a video comment. (Students will get the paper copy, too.)

I will be very curious to see how much they pay attention to the online version of the outcomes and grading scales. On the one hand, it’s transparent where I have clear expectations.1 On the other hand, students pay attention to such things differentially (sometimes judging that if instructions are very complicated, they’ll be discussed in class).

And now, I need to pay attention to the basics of running a compressed six-week course and ignore the temptation to play with Canvas some more…

If you enjoyed this post, please consider subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader, and sign up for my irregular newsletter below!


  1. On another assignment that’s unique to my section, students will construct the grading criteria/rubric within the categories I establish. []