Why Zotero beats LLMs, for me

I’ve avoided writing much about generative AI because the underlying technology has been shifting around too rapidly in the past 4 years for an historian to do much other than wave hands at the history of (education) technology and suggest people apply some perspective. But I have a real thought now!

I’ve come to rely on a critical academic infrastructure tool for my research in the past ten years. It’s transformed my productivity as a scholar, and while I just noodled on it during its early development, I suspected I’d use it heavily at some point. That’s Zotero, not ChatGPT or Claude or Muse or Gemini or Flibbijibbit 3.2 or whatever is the latest flavor of “it” LLMs. I think the reason is important to understanding technology as part of culture. (And yes, I agree with Farrell et al. that LLMs are cultural and social technologies.)

Continue reading “Why Zotero beats LLMs, for me”

Reasoning about and interpreting effect sizes: How big are they, really?

Half a century ago, educational psychologist Gene Glass coined a term for research synthesis, meta-analysis: “the term is a bit grand, but it is precise” (Glass, 1976, p. 3). Glass and Mary Lee Smith had wondered how to combine different studies about the effectiveness of behavioral and talk therapy, and decided that one way to do so would be to scale the magnitude of the effect by the standard deviation of the study sample. This effect size borrowed from the existing methodological literature on calculating the needed sample size for a study (e.g., Cohen, 1962), and Glass and Smith used this abstract measure of difference to average the differences each study claimed talk therapy made (or didn’t make) in the lives of therapy clients. 

Continue reading “Reasoning about and interpreting effect sizes: How big are they, really?”

Witch hunt for words

Note: this first appeared as a column in the Arizona Daily Star (Tucson) January 8, 2026.

When the Arizona Board of Education voted December 8 to remove anything smacking of “diversity, equity, and inclusion” from our Structured English Immersion curriculum and the Arizona Professional Teaching Standards, they were succumbing to this year’s witchhunt for words. 

In previous waves of ideological attacks on teachers and students, states have often been the battlefields. Historically, these attacks have narrowed the education that students receive, removing student access to effective teachers and to books that are part of our national heritage. The Arizona Board of Education’s vote should be seen as part of this longer history, this time focusing on a list of forbidden words. 

Continue reading “Witch hunt for words”

When others channel the Borg, look for the bagmen and the Borgias

Inevitability is a common rhetorical ploy in education. To Thomas Edison, film would inevitably replace textbooks. In the 1960s, B.F. Skinner said that teaching machines were inevitably going to replace teachers. In 2012, massive open online courses (MOOCs) were inevitably going to take over higher education. Pick your initiative, and you can almost always find someone who channels the Borg: resistance is futile. 

The Borg trope is wrong for many reasons. Few things are anywhere close to inevitable other than the heat death of the universe billions of years from now, or our personal mortality. Inevitability is often a rhetorical cover for what advocates cannot defend on their merits, especially in education. When someone tells me that resistance is futile, I look for clues to other dynamics: who is bearing the risk, who is actively shifting the potential risks, what might magnify inequalities, and where is the money? 

Continue reading “When others channel the Borg, look for the bagmen and the Borgias”