More net-flow SAS files

More test SAS files for state-level net flow from North Carolina in 2000-01, Massachusetts in 2000-01, and Massachusetts from the mid-1990s. As I’ve seen before I got the algorithm right, there’s a significant downtick for Mass. 2000-01 for 10th grade (or a higher-magnitude negative flow). You need several years of data after that point to know precisely how to interpret that datum. Is it a response to the implementation of either the high-stakes system with MCAS or the exit exam in Massachusetts? Hard to tell, exactly. Having seen anecdotal evidence of school-system responses to high-stakes testing, it might be evidence of a massive burp of triage/purging or of a student response. It’s the broader pattern that’s really necessary to tease things out.

One methods issue: there are two ways to think of smoothing data for small systems. One is to take annual data and smooth it. The other is to estimate two-year net-flows. Have to work on appropriate SAS statements for that.

The ‘multiculturalism’/’diversity’ tantrum

At least once a semester, at least one of my colleagues or I hear the following complaint from a student: “I’ve heard enough about diversity and multiculturalism!! Why can’t we just treat each other as human beings?” I’d hazard a guess that anyone who’s taught a social-foundations course in education or other classes where this topic pops up gets a similar complaint. It’s a minor vent/rage against the topic itself as well as a response to disturbing views that someone might be reading. And until recently, I didn’t understand it except as someone resisting the analysis required by the topic.

Continue reading “The ‘multiculturalism’/’diversity’ tantrum”

When you don’t have all grades…

One more idea: what to do with districts that aren’t unified—do not have students in all grades? There are bunches of districts in Texas and Massachusetts, for example, that have only elementary or only secondary grades. The iterative process for estimating student net flows relies on the whole grade span in two different ways—you need the upper grades to estimate the lower grades properly, and you need the lower grades to have a baseline net-migrant rate against which to compare the net-flow rates for high-school grades.

So the inverse (or converse) of a jackknife approach is called for.

Continue reading “When you don’t have all grades…”